Farnflower Newsletter
Calm

Does meditation actually work?

What mindfulness courses did for stress compared with doing nothing and with other activities, how little practice helped and what unpleasant effects occur.

Forested hills under a cloudy sky

Yes, modestly. Compared with doing nothing, mindfulness programs lowered anxiety, depression and psychological distress by a moderate amount, though confidence in that evidence is only moderate to low. Against other activities that also took time and attention, a clear advantage remained only for depression. In one trial, a short daily practice helped once people had kept it up for a while, and a minority of people find meditation unsettling.

Key takeaways

  • In a review of 136 trials, mindfulness programs reduced distress in adults outside clinical settings compared with no program.
  • Compared with other activities that also take time and attention, the advantage held only for depression.
  • An earlier review found no evidence that meditation beat drugs, exercise or other behavioral therapies.
  • In one trial, thirteen minutes a day helped after eight weeks but not yet after four.
  • Unpleasant experiences such as anxiety during or after meditation aren’t rare.

How well does mindfulness work against stress?

Modestly: better than doing nothing, with little clear advantage over other active approaches. A review led by researchers at the University of Cambridge pooled 136 randomized trials with 11,605 adults in nonclinical settings in 29 countries. Compared with people who got no program, those who took part in mindfulness courses had less anxiety, depression and psychological distress and better wellbeing one to six months later, in most but not all of the analyses. The authors rated their confidence in these results as moderate to very low and warned against assuming mindfulness works in every setting (Galante et al., 2021).

The comparison with other activities is where it gets interesting. Against control activities that also took time and attention, mindfulness still helped with depression but showed no clear advantage for anxiety or distress. Against specific other practices there was no evidence that mindfulness was better. When the researchers left out the trials at higher risk of bias, only the effect on distress remained, and trials from the United States reported smaller effects (Galante et al., 2021).

An earlier review from Johns Hopkins, which looked at 47 trials in people with various health problems, came to a similar view. Mindfulness programs improved anxiety, depression and pain by a small to moderate amount, with weaker evidence for stress and quality of life, and no evidence that meditation was better than drugs, exercise or other behavioral therapies (Goyal et al., 2014).

So mindfulness courses help on average, but little sets them apart from other things that take time and attention. I find that reassuring rather than disappointing: if sitting still isn’t for you, a walk, a run or another calming practice is a perfectly good route, and the research gives you permission to choose.

How much meditation do you need?

In one trial, thirteen minutes a day was enough after two months, though not after one. The reviews above mostly studied multi-week courses with group sessions, which is a bigger commitment than a short audio session at home. At New York University, adults aged 18 to 45 with no meditation experience listened either to a 13-minute guided meditation or to a 13-minute podcast every day. After eight weeks, the meditation group had a better mood, better attention and memory and less anxiety during a stressful speaking task. After four weeks, these differences hadn’t appeared yet (Basso et al., 2019). It was a single trial, so treat it as a hint, but its message fits ordinary life: a short daily habit, kept for two months, is a fair test.

Can meditation cause unpleasant experiences?

It can happen. A review of 83 studies with 6,703 people who meditated found that about 8 percent experienced an adverse event, most often anxiety, low mood or changes in thinking. The share was much lower in experimental studies than in observational ones, and some of these effects occurred in people with no history of mental health problems. The review counts what happened during or after meditation, mostly in studies not designed to test cause, so it can’t show how much meditation itself caused (Farias et al., 2020).

That doesn’t make meditation dangerous for most people. It does mean that if a practice leaves you more anxious or detached instead of calmer, stopping is the right reaction, and talking to a doctor or therapist is wise if the feeling stays.

What I’d do

  • Try ten to fifteen minutes of guided meditation a day for two months before you judge it, based on the one trial above.
  • Pick a fixed moment, such as right after coffee or before bed.
  • Switch to another calming practice if meditation doesn’t suit you; slow breathing is one option, as explained in Does slow breathing calm your nervous system?
  • Stop if meditation makes you feel worse, and talk to someone if it lasts.
  • See a doctor or therapist for an anxiety disorder or depression; a meditation app isn’t a treatment.
  • Be just as skeptical of apps that promise a sharper memory; Do brain games keep your mind sharp? looks at what those trials found.

Frequently asked questions

Do meditation apps count? The largest review looked mostly at in-person courses (Galante et al., 2021), and the New York trial used guided audio sessions (Basso et al., 2019). An app with guided sessions is closer to the latter, and none of the studies here compared apps.

Can meditation replace therapy or medication? Not on the evidence so far. The Johns Hopkins review found no sign that meditation programs worked better than drugs or other therapies (Goyal et al., 2014), and nobody has shown they can safely take their place, so talk to your doctor before changing a treatment. For everyday stress, time outdoors is another option with some evidence, as described in Does time in nature lower stress?

Sources

  • Basso, J. C., McHale, A., Ende, V., Oberlin, D. J., & Suzuki, W. A. (2019). Brief, daily meditation enhances attention, memory, mood, and emotional regulation in non-experienced meditators. Behavioural Brain Research, 356, 208–220. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bbr.2018.08.023
  • Farias, M., Maraldi, E., Wallenkampf, K. C., & Lucchetti, G. (2020). Adverse events in meditation practices and meditation-based therapies: A systematic review. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 142(5), 374–393. https://doi.org/10.1111/acps.13225
  • Galante, J., Friedrich, C., Dawson, A. F., Modrego-Alarcón, M., Gebbing, P., Delgado-Suárez, I., et al. (2021). Mindfulness-based programmes for mental health promotion in adults in nonclinical settings: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. PLoS Medicine, 18(1), e1003481. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1003481
  • Goyal, M., Singh, S., Sibinga, E. M., Gould, N. F., Rowland-Seymour, A., Sharma, R., et al. (2014). Meditation programs for psychological stress and well-being: A systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Internal Medicine, 174(3), 357–368. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2013.13018

One question a month, answered properly