Does slow breathing calm your nervous system?
What a few minutes of slow breathing changes in your heart rhythm and mood, how popular techniques compared in a Stanford trial, and where the hype starts.
Five minutes a day
Per session, the three breathing exercises lifted mood by similar amounts, and only cyclic sighing pulled clearly ahead of meditation over the month.
Average rise in positive mood per 5-minute session over one month (PANAS points, scale 10–50), 108 adults
Partly. Slowing your breath shifts your heart rhythm toward the pattern linked to the body’s calming branch, during the exercise and after programs of repeated sessions. In trials, breathwork of various kinds lowered stress and anxiety by a small to moderate amount, which makes it a useful everyday tool and not a cure.
Key takeaways
- A review of more than 200 studies found that heart rate variability, a marker linked to vagus nerve activity, rose with slow breathing.
- Across a dozen randomized trials, breathing exercises lowered self-reported stress by a small to moderate amount.
- In a one-month trial, only cyclic sighing lifted positive mood clearly more than mindfulness meditation did.
- Cyclic sighing, which has a long exhale, also lowered breathing rate over the month more than meditation.
- The same trial found no lasting change in heart rate variability in any group.
What does slow breathing do to your body?
It changes how your heart beats. Every breath in speeds the heart up slightly and every breath out slows it down, a normal pattern linked to activity of the vagus nerve (Balban et al., 2023), the main nerve of the body’s calming branch.
A review of 223 studies looked at what voluntary slow breathing does to heart rate variability, the beat-to-beat changes that reflect vagus nerve activity. The measure rose while people breathed slowly, right after a single session and after programs that lasted several sessions (Laborde et al., 2022). The authors call it a low-tech, low-cost technique with few expected side effects. A higher heart rate variability is a marker, though, and the review measured the marker, not long-term health.
Does it lower stress?
A little, according to trials of breathwork of various kinds. A review pooled 12 randomized trials with 785 adults and found that breathing exercises lowered self-reported stress compared with control conditions by a small to medium amount. Anxiety and depressive symptoms improved to a similar degree in other sets of trials. Most of the studies had a moderate risk of bias, and the authors themselves warn against letting the hype run ahead of the evidence (Fincham et al., 2023).
That warning fits. Breathing exercises are cheap and quick, and the effect is real and modest, which in my view is a perfectly good reason to use them on an ordinary Tuesday, between a difficult email and the next meeting. They aren’t a treatment for an anxiety disorder or depression; if worry or low mood shapes your days, talk to your doctor. Taping the mouth shut to force nasal breathing at night is a different idea with much thinner evidence, covered in Does mouth taping work?.
Which breathing technique works best?
No technique has been shown to be clearly best, and a head-to-head trial gives a modest answer. At Stanford, researchers randomly assigned 108 adults, most of them students, to five minutes a day of one of three breathing exercises or of mindfulness meditation, for one month, and everyone wore a wristband that recorded their breathing rate, heart rate and heart rate variability (Balban et al., 2023).
The three exercises
- Cyclic sighing: a slow breath in through the nose, a second short breath in to fill the lungs completely, then a long, slow breath out through the mouth.
- Box breathing: in, hold, out and hold for the same number of seconds each.
- Cyclic hyperventilation with retention: deep breaths in with relaxed breaths out, repeated, followed by holding the breath.
All four groups felt less anxious and less negative after their daily session, and meditation did as well as breathing on both. Positive mood rose more with breathing than with meditation when the three breathing groups were pooled, and that gap grew the longer people kept practicing. Taken one by one, only cyclic sighing was significantly ahead of meditation, both for the rise in positive mood over time and for the drop in breathing rate. No group showed a change in heart rate variability or resting heart rate over the month (Balban et al., 2023), so this trial doesn’t confirm the heart-rhythm effect from the review above as a lasting daily change. How meditation does on its own is explained in Does meditation actually work?
The card shows the per-session view. Each session lifted mood by almost the same amount across the three breathing exercises, with a lot of person-to-person spread, so the differences between them are small. Meditation lifted mood too, though less reliably. The groups were also small, from 21 to 33 people, the trial was exploratory and registered only after it had finished, and mood was self-reported. One of the authors, the neuroscientist Andrew Huberman, became an advisor to WHOOP, the maker of the wristband, in June 2022, according to the paper’s declaration of interests (Balban et al., 2023). I take cyclic sighing as a good first choice because it is easy and gentle, not because it has been proven superior.
What I’d do
- Try five minutes of cyclic sighing once a day, for example after work.
- Make the breath out clearly longer than the breath in.
- Use one or two slow sighs in the moment when stress spikes. Music is another easy option for tense moments, as Does listening to music lower stress? describes.
- Stop any technique that makes you feel light-headed or unwell, and start with the gentle ones.
- Ask your doctor before breath-holding exercises if you have heart or lung disease or are pregnant.
Frequently asked questions
Can coffee undo the calm? For people who are sensitive to caffeine, it can add to the jittery feeling. Who is affected and at which doses is in Does caffeine make anxiety worse?
Is stress always worth breathing away? Not all of it. Short bursts of stress are part of how the body performs, as explained in Is stress really bad for your health?
Sources
- Balban, M. Y., Neri, E., Kogon, M. M., Weed, L., Nouriani, B., Jo, B., et al. (2023). Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal. Cell Reports Medicine, 4(1), 100895. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.xcrm.2022.100895 (One author, A. D. Huberman, became an advisor to WHOOP in June 2022.)
- Fincham, G. W., Strauss, C., Montero-Marin, J., & Cavanagh, K. (2023). Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials. Scientific Reports, 13(1), 432. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-27247-y
- Laborde, S., Allen, M. S., Borges, U., Dosseville, F., Hosang, T. J., Iskra, M., et al. (2022). Effects of voluntary slow breathing on heart rate and heart rate variability: A systematic review and a meta-analysis. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 138, 104711. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2022.104711


