Farnflower Newsletter
Calm

Is stress really bad for your health?

Why a stressful speech and a stressful year do different things to your body, how big the risk from job stress is and what the famous mindset study can’t prove.

Storm clouds over forested hills

Short bursts of stress are a normal part of how the body works, and some immune responses even rise during them. Stress that lasts for months or years goes with a weaker immune system, and long-term stress at work with a modestly higher risk of heart disease, although tackling it would prevent far fewer cases than tackling smoking. The popular idea that stress only harms you if you believe it does goes further than the study behind it.

Key takeaways

  • Stress lasting minutes went with a rise in parts of the immune system, and stress lasting months with lower immune function.
  • Long-term stress at work went with a modestly higher risk of heart disease in large European studies.
  • The study behind “stress only harms you if you believe it does” can’t tell cause from effect.
  • Seeing a racing heart as useful energy improved how the body handled a stressful task in a small trial.
  • The long-term risks come from stress that lasts for months or years, which a change of mindset alone hasn’t been shown to fix.

Is all stress bad for you?

No. A review of more than 300 studies on stress and the immune system separated stress by how long it lasted. Stressors lasting minutes, such as giving a speech, were linked to a rise in parts of the immune system’s first line of defense, which the authors describe as potentially adaptive, while some other immune measures went down. Brief real-life stress such as exams had mixed effects. Chronic stress lasting months or years was linked to lower values on both main branches of immune measures (Segerstrom & Miller, 2004).

One detail from that review is easy to miss: how stressed people said they felt usually didn’t predict changes in their immune system (Segerstrom & Miller, 2004). What happened to them, and for how long, mattered more than the feeling they reported.

How much does long-term stress raise your risk?

For stress at work, measurably, but less than the big physical risk factors. Researchers pooled the individual data of 197,473 employed adults from 13 European cohort studies who had no heart disease at the start. People with job strain, meaning high demands combined with little control over their work, had a 23 percent higher risk of a first heart attack or death from heart disease during about seven and a half years, adjusted for age and sex. The link held after further adjustment. In published studies it looked larger than in the unpublished data the team added, a sign that the published literature had overstated it (Kivimäki et al., 2012).

The authors put that number into perspective themselves. They estimated that, if the link is causal, job strain accounts for about 3.4 percent of heart disease cases in these populations, and concluded that tackling workplace stress would prevent far fewer cases than tackling standard risk factors such as smoking (Kivimäki et al., 2012). I find that a useful correction to the idea that stress is the hidden cause of everything. It is a real risk and a moderate one.

Does stress only harm you if you believe it does?

That is the version that went viral, and the study can’t carry it. American researchers linked survey answers from 28,753 adults in 1998 to death records up to 2006. People who reported a lot of stress and also believed that stress affected their health a lot had a 43 percent higher risk of dying during that time than people with almost no stress (Keller et al., 2012). People with a lot of stress who didn’t believe it affected their health had no clearly higher risk (Keller et al., 2012).

The authors themselves warn about the obvious problem. Stress and the belief were measured only once, so the study can’t tell which came first, and reverse causation may partly explain the result: people who were already ill may have felt more stressed and noticed its effects on their health more (Keller et al., 2012). Imagine someone recovering from a heart attack who says that stress affects their health: they may simply be describing their situation correctly. So the finding is interesting, and it doesn’t show that changing a belief changes your lifespan.

Can the way you think about stress change your body?

In the short term, there is some evidence. At Harvard, 49 young adults gave a five-minute speech to two evaluators who reacted negatively throughout, then counted backward in steps of seven. Before the task, one group was told that a racing heart and fast breathing help the body perform. Compared with the control groups, this group showed a healthier pattern of heart and blood vessel responses and paid less attention to threatening information (Jamieson et al., 2012).

That is one small lab study in students, measured over minutes. It suggests a cheap thing to try before an exam or a presentation. It says nothing about years of caregiving, debt or an impossible job, which are the kinds of stress that the long-term studies link to illness.

What I’d do

  • Try treating the racing heart before a talk as fuel, and remind yourself of that before you start.
  • Look at what has been stressful for months, and change one practical thing about it. Writing it down may help a little, as Does journaling reduce stress? explains.
  • Keep up the basics that protect your heart anyway: movement, sleep and not smoking. Exercise also eases low mood and anxiety, as Does exercise improve your mood? shows.
  • Use a few minutes of slow breathing when stress spikes during the day; which technique did best in a trial is explained in Does slow breathing calm your nervous system?
  • See your doctor if stress affects your sleep, appetite or mood for more than a couple of weeks.

Frequently asked questions

Can stress cause high blood pressure? The studies in this article link long-term stress to heart disease, not specifically to lasting high blood pressure, so I can’t give a clean answer. Measuring is the way to know where you stand, as explained in What blood pressure numbers mean, and which habits lower them.

Does stress make you sleep worse? The studies in this article didn’t look at sleep. Common sleep stealers and what to change first are covered in the test What’s stealing your sleep?

Is caffeine making my stress worse? Sometimes. How strongly caffeine affects anxiety varies with the amount, with genes and with anxiety disorders. The evidence is explained in Does caffeine make anxiety worse?

Sources

  • Jamieson, J. P., Nock, M. K., & Mendes, W. B. (2012). Mind over matter: Reappraising arousal improves cardiovascular and cognitive responses to stress. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 141(3), 417–422. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0025719
  • Keller, A., Litzelman, K., Wisk, L. E., Maddox, T., Cheng, E. R., Creswell, P. D., & Witt, W. P. (2012). Does the perception that stress affects health matter? The association with health and mortality. Health Psychology, 31(5), 677–684. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0026743
  • Kivimäki, M., Nyberg, S. T., Batty, G. D., Fransson, E. I., Heikkilä, K., Alfredsson, L., et al. (2012). Job strain as a risk factor for coronary heart disease: A collaborative meta-analysis of individual participant data. The Lancet, 380(9852), 1491–1497. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(12)60994-5
  • Segerstrom, S. C., & Miller, G. E. (2004). Psychological stress and the human immune system: A meta-analytic study of 30 years of inquiry. Psychological Bulletin, 130(4), 601–630. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.130.4.601

One question a month, answered properly