Farnflower Newsletter
Drinks

Is fruit juice as healthy as eating fruit?

Juice keeps the sugar of the fruit but loses its structure. What studies found on diabetes, survival and weight, and how much juice is reasonable.

Fruit or juice

Whole fruit went with a lower risk of type 2 diabetes, fruit juice with a higher one.

Risk of type 2 diabetes for every 3 extra servings a week (no change = 100)

  1. Blueberries 74
  2. Grapes and raisins 88
  3. Apples and pears 93
  4. Fruit juice 108
Farnflower Source: Muraki et al., 2013 · 187,382 adults

No. Juice keeps the sugar of the fruit but loses most of what slows it down, so you drink it fast, stay hungry and get a different insulin response. In large American studies, whole fruit went with a lower risk of type 2 diabetes and juice with a higher one. A small glass now and then is fine; as a daily thirst quencher, juice behaves more like a sugary drink than like fruit. How juice counts toward daily limits is covered in the sugar limits article.

Key takeaways

  • People drank apple juice about eleven times faster than they ate the same amount of apples.
  • Juice left people less full, and their blood sugar dropped sharply afterward.
  • Blueberries, grapes and apples stood out as the fruits linked to the lowest diabetes risk.
  • In adults, juice didn’t clearly change body weight in trials; in children, more juice went with a slightly higher BMI.
  • The authors of one large study describe 100% juice as nutritionally similar to sugary drinks.

Why does juice act differently from the same fruit?

Juice acts differently because pressing the fruit removes its structure. In a classic British experiment, ten healthy adults ate apples, apple purée or apple juice, each with the same 60 grams of carbohydrate. They drank the juice about eleven times faster than they ate the apples. When the researchers made them consume all three at the same pace, juice was clearly the least filling and apples the most. Blood sugar rose to similar levels after all three, but after juice it then fell sharply again, a rebound dip that didn’t happen after apples. Insulin rose higher after juice and purée than after whole apples (Haber et al., 1977).

That experiment had only ten people. It is also almost fifty years old. Its message still makes sense, though, because it describes something everyone knows from their own kitchen, where three oranges take a good few minutes of peeling and chewing and leave you reasonably full, while the glass of juice squeezed from those same three oranges is gone in about as long as it takes to read this sentence.

Does fruit juice raise the risk of diabetes?

Yes, in the largest study on the question, fruit juice went with a higher risk of type 2 diabetes. Harvard researchers followed 187,382 nurses and health professionals for up to 24 years. After adjusting for diet and lifestyle, people who ate more whole fruit had a slightly lower risk of type 2 diabetes, with large differences between fruits. People who drank more fruit juice had a higher risk (Muraki et al., 2013).

The researchers also calculated what swapping juice for whole fruit would mean, and for most fruits, including apples, bananas, oranges and grapefruit, the swap went with a lower risk. That is the useful takeaway. You don’t have to give up the taste of orange, you just have to eat it.

Does drinking fruit juice shorten your life?

Fruit juice possibly shortens life in larger amounts. In the REGARDS study of 13,440 American adults aged 45 and older, each additional 12-ounce glass of 100% fruit juice a day went with a 24 percent higher risk of death during about six years of follow-up. The authors describe fruit juice as nutritionally similar to sugar-sweetened drinks and call for longer, larger studies (Collin et al., 2019). It is a single observational study. I wouldn’t panic over one glass, but it points the same way as the diabetes data.

Does fruit juice make you gain weight?

In adults, juice did not clearly change body weight, and in children it went with a slightly higher BMI. A 2024 review pooled 42 studies. In children, each extra daily serving of 100% juice went with a small increase in BMI over time. In adults, the trials found no clear effect on body weight, and the cohort results depended on how the studies were analyzed (Nguyen et al., 2024).

What I’d do

  • Eat fruit and drink water, a combination that beats juice on every measure above; the article on how many vegetables and fruits a day you need has the amounts.
  • Keep juice to a small glass with a meal if you enjoy it, rather than drinking it for thirst.
  • Dilute juice with sparkling water if you want the taste over a longer drink, since sparkling water is as hydrating as still water.
  • Give children water or milk as their everyday drink and keep juice small and occasional.
  • Choose berries, grapes and apples when you snack, the fruits with the clearest link to lower diabetes risk.

Frequently asked questions

Is freshly squeezed juice better than juice from a carton? Not much for these questions. Squeezing at home still removes most of the structure and fiber that make whole fruit filling, which is what the apple experiment showed.

How much fruit juice a day is okay? A small glass with a meal is a reasonable limit. In the REGARDS study, each additional 12-ounce glass a day went with a 24 percent higher risk of death (Collin et al., 2019), and for children I would keep juice small and occasional.

Are smoothies better than juice? Somewhat, because they keep the fiber. But blending also breaks the fruit’s structure, and in the apple experiment purée sat between whole apples and juice for fullness and insulin (Haber et al., 1977). More on blended fruit is in are smoothies as healthy as whole fruit.

Is juice better than diet soda? Not clearly. The authors of the REGARDS study describe 100% juice as nutritionally similar to sugar-sweetened drinks (Collin et al., 2019), while diet soda has its own questions, covered in Are diet sodas bad for you?

Sources

  • Collin, L. J., Judd, S., Safford, M., Vaccarino, V., & Welsh, J. A. (2019). Association of sugary beverage consumption with mortality risk in US adults: A secondary analysis of data from the REGARDS study. JAMA Network Open, 2(5), e193121. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2019.3121
  • Haber, G. B., Heaton, K. W., Murphy, D., & Burroughs, L. F. (1977). Depletion and disruption of dietary fibre: Effects on satiety, plasma-glucose, and serum-insulin. The Lancet, 2(8040), 679–682. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(77)90494-9
  • Muraki, I., Imamura, F., Manson, J. E., Hu, F. B., Willett, W. C., van Dam, R. M., & Sun, Q. (2013). Fruit consumption and risk of type 2 diabetes: Results from three prospective longitudinal cohort studies. BMJ, 347, f5001. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.f5001
  • Nguyen, M., Jarvis, S. E., Chiavaroli, L., Mejia, S. B., Zurbau, A., Khan, T. A., et al. (2024). Consumption of 100% fruit juice and body weight in children and adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Pediatrics, 178(3), 237–246. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapediatrics.2023.6124

One question a month, answered properly