Farnflower Newsletter
Move

Cardio or strength training: which matters more for a long life?

In large observational studies, people who did both cardio and strength training had the lowest risk of early death, and the first hour a week gave the most.

Does your week meet the guidelines? Take the one-minute test

Cardio, strength or both

Meeting both exercise guidelines went with the lowest risk of early death.

Risk of dying during follow-up by guideline met (cardio = 150 min of moderate activity a week; strength = 2 or more sessions a week; neither = 100), 80,306 adults in England and Scotland

  1. Neither guideline 100
  2. Cardio guideline only 84
  3. Strength guideline only 79
  4. Both guidelines 71
Farnflower Source: Stamatakis et al., 2018 · 11 cohorts from the Health Survey for England and the Scottish Health Survey

Both. In large observational studies, people who did only cardio or only strength training had a lower risk of dying early than people who did neither, and those who did both had the lowest risk. The benefit of each grew fastest with the first hour or session a week and then leveled off.

Key takeaways

  • In British data, the cardio guideline went with fewer deaths from heart disease and the strength guideline with fewer deaths from cancer.
  • In a study of more than 400,000 Americans, the benefit of cardio leveled off at about three hours a week.
  • One or two strength sessions a week went with a modest extra benefit, while daily sessions showed none.
  • In patients who took a treadmill test, below-average fitness carried a risk similar to smoking or diabetes.
  • Weaker grip strength went with a higher risk of death across 17 countries.

Is cardio or strength training linked to a longer life?

Cardio and strength training are both linked to a longer life, and the pattern differs a little. The US guidelines ask adults for 150 to 300 minutes of moderate aerobic activity a week plus muscle-strengthening activities on two or more days (Piercy et al., 2018). A pooled analysis of 11 population cohorts from English and Scottish health surveys compared people by which of the two they met. Meeting only the cardio guideline went with fewer deaths from heart disease, meeting only the strength guideline with fewer deaths from cancer, and meeting both with the lowest risk of dying from any cause (Stamatakis et al., 2018). The differences between the three active groups were small and their margins of error overlapped, so I read this as “both help”, not as a ranking.

A review of 16 cohort studies points the same way. Strength training was linked with a lower risk of early death, heart disease, cancer and diabetes, and doing strength training and aerobic activity together went with a clearly lower risk of dying than doing neither (Momma et al., 2022). Only three of the studies looked at the combination, and the review rated the overall quality of the evidence on early death as very low. All of these are observational studies in which people described their own exercise, so they can’t show cause and effect, and active people tend to have other healthy habits too.

How many hours of cardio do you need?

The benefit of cardio levels off at about three hours a week, with most of the gain in the first hour. Researchers linked US health surveys from 416,420 adults to death records. Just one hour a week of moderate or vigorous aerobic activity went with a clearly lower risk of dying during follow-up, more hours added less and less, and the benefit leveled off at about three hours; for older adults, the risk fell only slightly beyond that. The pattern was similar for women and men (Coleman et al., 2022). Brisk walking counts, as described in Is walking enough exercise? Whether easy cardio is enough or harder efforts add something is the subject of Is zone 2 training worth it?

How much strength training is enough for a longer life?

The benefit of strength training levels off early. In the same US data, people who did strength training once a week on top of their aerobic activity had a modestly lower risk of dying, the minimum effective dose was one to two sessions a week, and people who did strength training seven times a week showed no benefit any more (Coleman et al., 2022). The review of 16 cohorts found the largest benefit at roughly half an hour to an hour a week (Momma et al., 2022). What that looks like in practice is in How much strength training do you need a week?

I wouldn’t read the missing benefit at the top end as proof that lots of lifting is harmful. Very few people train daily, so the estimates there are uncertain, and the people who do may differ in ways the surveys didn’t capture.

What do fitness tests say about a long life?

Fitness tests give a measured version of the same story, and this is the part I find most striking. At the Cleveland Clinic, researchers looked at 122,007 adults who had done a treadmill test for medical reasons and followed them for a median of eight years. The fitter people were, the lower their risk of dying, and the researchers observed no upper limit: the elite group, roughly the fittest 2 percent for their age and sex, had the lowest risk of all. People with below-average fitness were more likely to die during follow-up than those with above-average fitness, to about the same degree as smokers compared with non-smokers or people with diabetes compared with those without (Mandsager et al., 2018). These were patients sent for a test, so the results may not apply to everyone, and fitness partly reflects health that exercise can’t change.

Strength shows a similar signal in a different population. The PURE study measured the grip strength of 139,691 adults aged 35 to 70 in 17 countries with a simple hand device and followed them for four years. Every 5 kilograms less grip strength went with a 16 percent higher risk of dying from any cause (Leong et al., 2015). Grip strength is often used as a quick stand-in for overall strength, and I found no evidence that training your grip alone extends life.

The two studies looked at different people and didn’t adjust for each other, so they can’t tell you which matters more. My own reading is simple: cardio builds the kind of fitness the treadmill measures, strength training the kind the hand device measures, and it makes sense to look after both.

What I’d do

  • Start with whichever kind you will actually do, then add the other.
  • Aim for the 150 minutes of moderate cardio a week that the guidelines ask for, including brisk walks.
  • Add one or two strength sessions a week.
  • Keep a short session going in busy weeks, because a small dose protects most of your fitness, as How long does it take to lose fitness? explains.
  • Ask your doctor before starting hard training if you have a heart condition.
  • Swap a long stretching routine for strength work if time is short, since Does stretching prevent injuries? shows which one protects you better.

Frequently asked questions

Can you do too much cardio? For the risk of dying early, the Cleveland Clinic study observed no upper limit to the benefit of fitness (Mandsager et al., 2018). That study measured fitness, not training hours; for weekly hours, the US data showed the benefit leveling off rather than turning negative (Coleman et al., 2022).

How much exercise do you need to live longer? The guidelines ask for 150 to 300 minutes of moderate cardio a week plus strength training on two or more days (Piercy et al., 2018), but in the US data one hour of cardio a week and one or two strength sessions already went with a lower risk (Coleman et al., 2022).

Do women need strength training too? Yes. The US guidelines recommend muscle-strengthening activities for all adults (Piercy et al., 2018).

Does it matter which kind of strength training I do? The review of 16 cohorts counted both weight training and exercises with your own body weight (Momma et al., 2022), so the form that you keep doing is the right one to start with.

Sources

  • Coleman, C. J., McDonough, D. J., Pope, Z. C., & Pope, C. A. (2022). Dose–response association of aerobic and muscle-strengthening physical activity with mortality: A national cohort study of 416 420 US adults. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 56(21), 1218–1223. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2022-105519
  • Leong, D. P., Teo, K. K., Rangarajan, S., Lopez-Jaramillo, P., Avezum, A., Jr., Orlandini, A., et al. (2015). Prognostic value of grip strength: Findings from the Prospective Urban Rural Epidemiology (PURE) study. The Lancet, 386(9990), 266–273. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(14)62000-6
  • Mandsager, K., Harb, S., Cremer, P., Phelan, D., Nissen, S. E., & Jaber, W. (2018). Association of cardiorespiratory fitness with long-term mortality among adults undergoing exercise treadmill testing. JAMA Network Open, 1(6), e183605. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2018.3605
  • Momma, H., Kawakami, R., Honda, T., & Sawada, S. S. (2022). Muscle-strengthening activities are associated with lower risk and mortality in major non-communicable diseases: A systematic review and meta-analysis of cohort studies. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 56(13), 755–763. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2021-105061
  • Piercy, K. L., Troiano, R. P., Ballard, R. M., Carlson, S. A., Fulton, J. E., Galuska, D. A., George, S. M., & Olson, R. D. (2018). The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans. JAMA, 320(19), 2020–2028. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2018.14854
  • Stamatakis, E., Lee, I.-M., Bennie, J., Freeston, J., Hamer, M., O’Donovan, G., et al. (2018). Does strength-promoting exercise confer unique health benefits? A pooled analysis of data on 11 population cohorts with all-cause, cancer, and cardiovascular mortality endpoints. American Journal of Epidemiology, 187(5), 1102–1112. https://doi.org/10.1093/aje/kwx345

One question a month, answered properly