Farnflower Newsletter
Eat

Does 16:8 fasting work?

In two trials, an eight-hour eating window added little once calories were equal, and one trial saw some muscle loss. Who 16:8 can still suit.

16:8 against calorie counting

With the same calorie target, adding an eight-hour eating window didn’t lead to clearly more weight loss.

Average weight loss after 12 months, 139 adults with obesity, both groups on the same calorie target

  1. Calories + eating window −8.0 kg
  2. Calories only −6.3 kg
Farnflower Source: Liu et al., 2022 · difference not statistically significant

Fasting for sixteen hours a day works about as well as other ways of eating less, and no better. In the trials below, the eight-hour window on its own changed little, and when both groups ate the same calories, it made no clear difference. If skipping breakfast or late snacks makes it easier for you to eat less, it is a reasonable tool. Otherwise, there is no reason to force it.

Key takeaways

  • Against three ordinary meals a day without other advice, 16:8 led to almost no extra weight loss in a 12-week trial.
  • In that trial, part of the weight the fasting group lost was lean mass.
  • Over a full year, 16:8 plus calorie counting did not clearly beat calorie counting alone.
  • Waist size, body fat and metabolic risk factors showed no clear difference between the groups either.
  • If you do 16:8, enough protein and some strength training help protect your muscle.

Does 16:8 work if you only change the eating window?

Changing only the eating window did very little. In the TREAT trial at the University of California, San Francisco, 116 adults with overweight were randomly assigned either to eat three regular meals a day or to eat freely between noon and 8 pm and nothing outside that window, for 12 weeks. The fasting group lost a little weight, but the difference between the groups was tiny and not statistically meaningful, and the two groups reported eating similar amounts (Lowe et al., 2020).

There was one worrying detail. In the 50 participants who were measured in person, the fasting group lost more lean mass in the arms and legs than the regular-meal group (Lowe et al., 2020). Losing muscle is not the kind of weight loss most people want. It matters more with age.

Is 16:8 better than counting calories?

16:8 was not clearly better than counting calories. In a year-long trial in Guangzhou, China, 139 adults with obesity were all put on the same calorie target, women 1,200 to 1,500 and men 1,500 to 1,800 calories a day. Half of them also ate only between 8 am and 4 pm. Both groups lost a lot of weight, and although the fasting group lost a little more, the difference was small enough that chance could easily explain it. Waist size, body fat, blood pressure and blood sugar told the same story (Liu et al., 2022).

This is the trial I’d point to when someone says the eating window itself burns fat. Once calories are equal, the window adds little (Liu et al., 2022). What it can do is make eating less easier for some people, because it removes the late-evening snack or the second breakfast without much thought. Cutting calories overall is a different question, and whether it helps you live longer is covered in does eating less help you live longer.

Who is 16:8 right for, and who should skip it?

16:8 suits people who find a rule about when easier than a rule about how much, who aren’t hungry in the morning anyway (randomized trials found little weight difference between eating and skipping breakfast), and who tend to snack late in the evening. An earlier window, finishing in the afternoon, also fits what the late-night eating article describes.

16:8 is less suitable for people with diabetes on insulin or tablets that lower blood sugar, for pregnant or breastfeeding women, and for anyone with a history of eating disorders. If that applies to you, talk to your doctor first.

What I’d do

  • Try 16:8 only if it makes eating less easier for you, and stop if it leads to overeating in the window.
  • Choose an earlier window, such as 9 am to 5 pm, if your days allow it.
  • Eat enough protein inside the window, as the protein article explains.
  • Keep up strength training to protect your muscle, and see the strength training article for how much counts.
  • Drink water, tea or black coffee during the fasting hours, and keep the coffee early, as the coffee cutoff article explains.

Frequently asked questions

Does coffee break a fast? Black coffee and plain tea add almost no calories, so in practical terms they don’t. Neither does water. Milk and sugar do.

Is 16:8 safe for women? Both trials included women, and the year-long trial found no substantial difference in side effects between the groups (Liu et al., 2022). Pregnant and breastfeeding women and anyone with a history of eating disorders should avoid it unless their doctor agrees.

Is it okay to train while fasted? The two trials above didn’t test it. For muscle, the evidence is strongest for regular strength training and enough protein across the day, as explained in How much protein do you need a day?

Sources

  • Liu, D., Huang, Y., Huang, C., Yang, S., Wei, X., Zhang, P., et al. (2022). Calorie restriction with or without time-restricted eating in weight loss. The New England Journal of Medicine, 386(16), 1495–1504. https://doi.org/10.1056/nejmoa2114833
  • Lowe, D. A., Wu, N., Rohdin-Bibby, L., Moore, A. H., Kelly, N., Liu, Y. E., et al. (2020). Effects of time-restricted eating on weight loss and other metabolic parameters in women and men with overweight and obesity: The TREAT randomized clinical trial. JAMA Internal Medicine, 180(11), 1491–1499. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2020.4153

One question a month, answered properly