Farnflower Newsletter
Eat

Does eating less help you live longer?

What long monkey studies and a two-year human trial found about cutting calories, how much people really managed, and what it cost their bones.

The CALERIE trial, planned vs real

Healthy adults asked to eat a quarter fewer calories for two years managed about half of that and lost about a tenth of their weight.

Percent, restriction group after two years

  1. Calorie cut planned 25%
  2. Calorie cut achieved 11.7%
  3. Body weight lost 10.4%
Farnflower Source: Ravussin et al., 2015 · 218 adults

Eating fewer calories extends life in many animals, and in humans it improves several markers linked to aging, but no human trial has yet run long enough to show that it makes people live longer. In the largest human trial, healthy adults managed to cut their calories by only about half of what was planned, and even that slightly slowed one measure of biological aging. It also cost some bone, so for most people, avoiding overeating is a more realistic goal than strict restriction.

Key takeaways

  • In rhesus monkeys, long-term calorie restriction improved health, and a comparison of two long studies concluded it also improved survival.
  • In a two-year human trial, healthy adults who cut calories had lower cardiovascular risk factors without a drop in quality of life.
  • The same trial slowed one DNA-based measure of the pace of aging slightly, while other aging clocks didn’t change.
  • People in the restriction group lost a little bone density at the hip and spine.
  • Exercise-induced weight loss didn’t cause the same bone loss in a separate trial.

What did the monkey studies find?

In rhesus monkeys, calorie restriction improved health, and a comparison of two long studies concluded it improved survival too. The two studies began in the late 1980s, one at the University of Wisconsin and one at the US National Institute on Aging. Wisconsin reported that calorie restriction improved survival, while the NIA study found no significant effect on survival, which led to years of debate. When both teams compared their data directly, they traced the difference to study design, including when restriction started and what the monkeys ate, and concluded that the health benefits of restriction hold in monkeys (Mattison et al., 2017).

What happened in the human trial?

In the CALERIE trial, healthy adults who cut calories for two years lowered their cardiovascular risk factors without harm to their quality of life. The trial randomly assigned 218 adults aged 21 to 51 without obesity either to cut their calories by 25 percent or to eat as usual. The restriction group achieved much less than planned but kept off about a tenth of their body weight, and compared with the control group their risk factors dropped further. Their bodies also burned slightly less energy each day than their new weight predicted (Ravussin et al., 2015).

A later analysis of blood samples from the same trial looked at DNA methylation, chemical marks on DNA that change with age. Calorie restriction slowed the pace of aging measured by one algorithm, DunedinPACE, but didn’t change biological age estimates from other clocks such as PhenoAge and GrimAge. The authors describe the effects as small and point out that only long trials measuring disease and death can settle the question (Waziry et al., 2023).

Does eating less have downsides?

Yes, bone is the clearest one. In CALERIE, the restriction group lost more bone mineral density at the spine and hip than the control group over two years, and they also lost some lean mass along with fat (Villareal et al., 2016). In an earlier one-year trial with 48 adults in their fifties, weight loss from calorie restriction reduced hip and spine bone density, while a similar weight loss from exercise didn’t. The authors recommend exercise as part of any weight loss plan to protect bone (Villareal et al., 2006).

Strength training is the obvious partner here, as explained in How much strength training do you need a week? Older adults, people with a history of eating disorders and anyone underweight shouldn’t restrict calories without medical advice.

Is intermittent fasting the same thing?

No, because fasting changes when you eat, while calorie restriction changes how much. What the trials on it found is in Does 16:8 fasting work?

What I’d do

  • Stop eating when you are comfortably full rather than counting every calorie.
  • Keep protein and strength training up if you are trying to eat less.
  • Ask your doctor before trying long-term calorie restriction, especially after 60.
  • Treat claims that fasting or restriction will add years to your life as unproven in humans.

Frequently asked questions

How much did people in CALERIE actually eat? They aimed for 25 percent fewer calories but averaged about 12 percent fewer over two years (Ravussin et al., 2015), which shows how hard strict restriction is to keep up.

Is the Okinawan diet an example of calorie restriction? Researchers who studied six decades of data on older Okinawans found low calorie intake and lifelong low body weight, which they read as support for the idea, as described in What do people in the Blue Zones really eat?

Can exercise protect my bones while I eat less? In the one-year trial, weight loss from exercise didn’t reduce hip and spine bone density the way weight loss from calorie restriction did (Villareal et al., 2006).

Sources

  • Mattison, J. A., Colman, R. J., Beasley, T. M., Allison, D. B., Kemnitz, J. W., Roth, G. S., et al. (2017). Caloric restriction improves health and survival of rhesus monkeys. Nature Communications, 8, 14063. https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms14063
  • Ravussin, E., Redman, L. M., Rochon, J., Das, S. K., Fontana, L., Kraus, W. E., et al. (2015). A 2-year randomized controlled trial of human caloric restriction: Feasibility and effects on predictors of health span and longevity. The Journals of Gerontology: Series A, 70(9), 1097–1104. https://doi.org/10.1093/gerona/glv057
  • Villareal, D. T., Fontana, L., Das, S. K., Redman, L., Smith, S. R., Saltzman, E., et al. (2016). Effect of two-year caloric restriction on bone metabolism and bone mineral density in non-obese younger adults: A randomized clinical trial. Journal of Bone and Mineral Research, 31(1), 40–51. https://doi.org/10.1002/jbmr.2701
  • Villareal, D. T., Fontana, L., Weiss, E. P., Racette, S. B., Steger-May, K., Schechtman, K. B., et al. (2006). Bone mineral density response to caloric restriction-induced weight loss or exercise-induced weight loss: A randomized controlled trial. Archives of Internal Medicine, 166(22), 2502–2510. https://doi.org/10.1001/archinte.166.22.2502
  • Waziry, R., Ryan, C. P., Corcoran, D. L., Huffman, K. M., Kobor, M. S., Kothari, M., et al. (2023). Effect of long-term caloric restriction on DNA methylation measures of biological aging in healthy adults from the CALERIE trial. Nature Aging, 3(3), 248–257. https://doi.org/10.1038/s43587-022-00357-y

One question a month, answered properly