Farnflower Newsletter
Eat

Is chicken healthier than red meat?

Long-term data on chicken, red meat and fish point one way, while a controlled feeding trial found that both meats raised LDL cholesterol alike.

Meat, fish and the risk of dying

Processed and unprocessed red meat went with a slightly higher risk of dying, while chicken and fish didn’t.

Risk of death for every 2 extra servings a week (no extra = 1.00)

  1. No extra servings 1.00
  2. Fish 0.99
  3. Poultry 0.99
  4. Unprocessed red meat 1.03
  5. Processed meat 1.03
Farnflower Source: Zhong et al., 2020 · 29,682 adults

In long-term studies, people who ate more chicken didn’t have a higher risk of dying, while people who ate more red or processed meat did, so chicken looks like the better choice for a long life. For heart health the picture is less clear-cut. A controlled feeding trial found that chicken raised LDL cholesterol just as much as beef, and only meals without meat kept it lower.

Key takeaways

  • In six pooled American cohorts, red and processed meat were linked to a slightly higher risk of dying; poultry and fish weren’t.
  • Poultry was linked to a slightly higher risk of cardiovascular disease in the same data, which the study couldn’t explain.
  • In a feeding trial, LDL cholesterol was the same after weeks of red meat and of white meat, and lower after plant protein.
  • Saturated fat raised LDL cholesterol whichever protein people ate.

What do the long-term studies show?

A small difference in favor of chicken. Researchers pooled six American cohorts with 29,682 adults who were followed for a median of 19 years. Each extra two servings a week of processed meat or unprocessed red meat went with a slightly higher risk of dying and of cardiovascular disease, whereas poultry and fish, eaten in the same extra amounts, showed no link with the risk of dying at all. Poultry, however, was linked to a slightly higher risk of cardiovascular disease, while fish wasn’t (Zhong et al., 2020).

The authors called these increases small and asked for further research, and the study is observational. Nobody can tell from it why poultry and heart disease went together.

Does chicken raise cholesterol less than beef?

No. In a randomized trial, generally healthy adults ate three diets for four weeks each in random order, with similar amounts of protein coming from red meat, from white meat or from nonmeat sources; 113 of them completed all three. One group ate these diets with a high saturated fat content, the other with a low one. LDL cholesterol and apolipoprotein B were higher on both meat diets than on the plant diet, and red and white meat didn’t differ. Higher saturated fat raised LDL cholesterol whatever the protein source (Bergeron et al., 2019).

The authors concluded that their results support diets with a high share of plant foods but don’t, by themselves, justify choosing white meat over red meat for heart health. The trial was funded by the US National Institutes of Health.

So which is better?

Chicken, by a small margin. It has the edge for overall mortality in the cohort data, and plants have the edge over both meats for cholesterol in the trial. The most consistent finding across both is that processed meat and saturated fat are the bigger problems, as Is red meat bad for you? and Is saturated fat bad for you? explain.

What I’d do

  • Choose chicken or fish over red meat on most days you eat meat.
  • Keep processed meats such as sausage, bacon and ham occasional.
  • Keep saturated fat low whichever protein you choose, since it raised LDL cholesterol in the feeding trial.
  • Replace some meat meals with beans, lentils or tofu, as described in Plant protein vs animal protein.

Frequently asked questions

Is fish better than chicken? In the American cohorts, fish wasn’t linked to cardiovascular disease, while poultry was linked to a slightly higher risk (Zhong et al., 2020). How much fish is sensible each week is covered in How much fish is safe to eat a week?

Is chicken skin bad for you? The studies here didn’t look at skin separately, so they can’t say. What they do show is that higher saturated fat raised LDL cholesterol in the feeding trial (Bergeron et al., 2019).

Is processed meat worse than fresh red meat? In the pooled American cohorts, both were linked to about the same small increase in the risk of dying for every two extra servings a week (Zhong et al., 2020).

Sources

  • Bergeron, N., Chiu, S., Williams, P. T., King, S. M., & Krauss, R. M. (2019). Effects of red meat, white meat, and nonmeat protein sources on atherogenic lipoprotein measures in the context of low compared with high saturated fat intake: A randomized controlled trial. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 110(1), 24–33. https://doi.org/10.1093/ajcn/nqz035 (Corrigendum: 110(3), 783.)
  • Zhong, V. W., Van Horn, L., Greenland, P., Carnethon, M. R., Ning, H., Wilkins, J. T., et al. (2020). Associations of processed meat, unprocessed red meat, poultry, or fish intake with incident cardiovascular disease and all-cause mortality. JAMA Internal Medicine, 180(4), 503–512. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2019.6969

One question a month, answered properly